Beyond the Bruise: How to Deal With Negative Feedback

There’s a particular jolt that comes with negative feedback. One moment you’re in a meeting, thinking about your next project deadline; the next, someone has handed you a critique that lands like a punch you didn’t see coming.

Our brains treat criticism as a form of social threat, and we respond as if we’ve just been cornered.

For many, the instinctive reaction is predictable: defend, explain, or retreat. That’s human—and it’s wired into us. Our brains treat criticism as a form of social threat, and we respond as if we’ve just been cornered. But here’s the thing: the leaders who grow the fastest aren’t the ones who avoid the sting—they’re the ones who manage the moment so they can mine the value inside it.

Step One: Master Your Physiology Before Your Words

When feedback feels harsh or unexpected, your body reacts before your brain does. A faster heartbeat, shallow breathing, tightened muscles—these are your fight-or-flight signals.

One simple way to regain control: the 4–7 breath. Inhale for four seconds, exhale for seven. That longer exhale tells your nervous system it’s safe to stand down.

Coach’s tip: Practice this breathing technique in low-stakes moments so it’s second nature when you actually need it.

Step Two: Name What You’re Feeling

Labeling your emotions—“I’m feeling embarrassed and frustrated right now”—activates the rational part of your brain. It’s not about announcing your feelings to the room; it’s about signaling to yourself that you can observe them without being ruled by them.

Coach’s tip: Keep your labels precise. “I’m feeling defensive” is more useful than “I’m upset” because it points you toward the underlying trigger.

Step Three: Get Curious, Not Furious

Instead of countering the feedback, shift into inquiry mode. Pretend for a moment the conversation is about someone else. Ask, “Can you give me a specific example?” or “Help me understand what that looked like from your perspective.”

Curiosity signals openness—and often transforms the tone of the exchange.

Coach’s tip: Avoid “Why?” in the heat of the moment. It can sound accusatory. Use “What” or “How” questions to keep the dialogue constructive.

Step Four: Buy Yourself Processing Time

It’s rarely wise to agree or disagree on the spot. Thank the person for their input, let them know you want to reflect, and set a time to follow up if needed. This prevents knee-jerk responses and gives you space to assess what’s true, what’s perception, and what requires action.

Coach’s tip: A simple script works wonders: “I appreciate you bringing this up. I’d like to think about it and circle back.”

Step Five: Extract the Useful Parts

Not all feedback is equally valid, but almost all of it contains something useful—if only as a window into how you’re being perceived. Even if you disagree with 80% of what was said, the other 20% may hold a clue that can help you improve or communicate more effectively.

Coach’s tip: Write down the feedback in your own words after the meeting. Separating it from the emotional charge often reveals insights you missed in the moment.

Step Six: Keep the Door Open

When you respond to feedback with grace—especially tough feedback—you make it more likely people will come to you directly next time instead of going around you. That’s how you prevent small issues from festering into major problems.

Coach’s tip: Even if you strongly disagree with the feedback, thank the person for bringing it to you. You’re not thanking them for being right—you’re thanking them for their willingness to speak up.

Final thought

Negative feedback is never comfortable, but comfort isn’t the goal—growth is. When you can handle the sting without losing your balance, you gain more than a better skill set. You gain the trust of the people around you, and that’s a currency every leader needs.

---

👉🏽Do you want more real-life leadership tips? Sign up for the Monday Morning Mentoring YouTube channel and the ILS bi-weekly newsletter. Also, follow me on LinkedIn.